CO2 Refill vs Exchange: Which Places Fill Your Own Tank (and Which Only Swap)

"Do you fill, or just swap?" is the first question to ask any CO2 shop, and Google Maps almost never tells you the answer. Here is what each one means, when each is the better deal, and how to tell before you drive over.

Refill (fill your own tank)

The shop puts CO2 into your cylinder and hands the same cylinder back.

  • You keep your tank (new, aluminum, the right size for your kegerator).
  • The tank has to be within its hydro-test date.
  • Sometimes it's while-you-wait, sometimes you drop it off for a few hours or a day.

Exchange (swap)

You hand over your empty and leave with a different full cylinder of the same size.

  • It's fast: no waiting for a fill.
  • The shop deals with hydro testing, so an out-of-date tank is often fine to trade in (ask).
  • You may get an older, scuffed or steel tank back for your shiny new one.

The hydro-test rule (why shops turn tanks away)

US DOT-spec CO2 cylinders must be visually inspected and hydrostatically retested every five years. A cylinder can be emptied after its date passes, but it has to be retested before anyone refills it (Catalina Cylinders, citing 49 CFR Part 180). The last test date is stamped on the shoulder of the tank as month/year. Shops that fill your own tank check it. For example:

Rule of thumb: if your tank is out of date, compare the retest fee (about $39 at the shop above) plus the fill against a straight exchange. If the tank is new or a size you love, refill and keep it.

Which kinds of places do which?

This varies shop by shop, but here's what we found in the pages we checked:

Type of businessUsuallyReal examples
Beverage-gas / CO2 suppliersOften fill your own tank; food-gradeGiant CO2 (fills while you wait); Air Source Industries, Long Beach (same-day food-grade refills: drop off in the morning, pick up in the afternoon)
Homebrew shopsMixed: many swap only, some fillStein Fillers (exchange program); SoCal Brewing Supply, Vista: "exchange-only… we do not refill customer tanks onsite", $29.99 for 5 lb (source); Tavern Service, Northridge (fills on site in minutes, and exchanges)
Paintball shopsFill small tanks while you wait; some do 5 lbAdrenaline Paintball, Gardena (up to 24 oz, and kegerator tanks up to 5 lb)
Welding / industrial gas storesCommonly swap; may not stock beverage gradeAirgas stores list carbon dioxide but don't say whether they fill your own tank. Ask.
SodaStream retailers and small exchangersExchange only (60L soda cylinders)SodaStream options after Bed Bath & Beyond

Five questions to ask on the phone

  1. "Do you fill my own tank, or exchange only?"
  2. "Is it food-grade / beverage-grade CO2?" (This matters for kegerators and soda makers.)
  3. "What sizes do you do, and what's the price for a [5 / 10 / 20] lb?"
  4. "Is it while-you-wait or drop-off? What time do fills stop?" (Some shops stop fills early in the day.)
  5. "My tank was last tested [month/year]. Is that OK?"

Los Angeles: places that say they fill your own tank

PlaceCityServiceFood-gradeQuick ConnectPrice
FizzFill – Highland ParkLos Angeles (Highland Park)Fill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – InglewoodInglewoodFill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – Mid-CityLos AngelesFill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – Santa Clarita (Castaic)Santa ClaritaFill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – Toluca LakeLos Angeles (Toluca Lake)Fill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – TorranceTorranceFill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
FizzFill – West HollywoodWest HollywoodFill + swapYesYes$12 per 60L exchange (FizzFill FAQ)
Air Source IndustriesLong BeachFill + swapYes??
South Bay Brewing Supply Co.TorranceFill + swap???
Tavern Service (HomeBeer.com)NorthridgeFill + swap???

? = not yet confirmed. Call ahead.

PlaceCityServiceFood-gradeQuick ConnectPrice
Adrenaline Paintball & AirsoftGardenaFills your tank??$12 CO2 up to 24 oz (incl. SodaStream); $45 kegerator tank up to 5 lb; $5 HPA

? = not yet confirmed. Call ahead.

Every place, including exchange-only and not-yet-confirmed ones: CO2 refill and exchange in Los Angeles.

FAQ

Is it cheaper to refill or exchange a CO2 tank?
It depends on the shop. A fill of your own in-date tank is often similar to or cheaper than an exchange. If your tank is out of hydro-test date, an exchange can come out cheaper than paying for a retest and then a fill.
Why won't a shop fill my CO2 tank?
Usually the cylinder is past its five-year hydrostatic test date, or it isn't a DOT/ISO-marked cylinder. Some shops simply don't fill certain types, like SodaStream or paintball cylinders.
Will I get my own tank back with an exchange?
No. An exchange gives you a different filled cylinder of the same size. If you want to keep your tank, look for a shop that fills your own.
Does welding CO2 work for a kegerator?
Ask for food-grade or beverage-grade CO2 for anything you drink. Some industrial gas suppliers also sell beverage-grade CO2, but don't assume the counter you're at has it. Ask.